Vincent St Aubyn Crump – February 2009
Atopic eczema or atopic dermatitis in children, along with the other atopic diseases, asthma & hay fever (allergic rhinitis), has considerably increased in Western population over the last 30 years (almost tripled). The prevalence is about 10-20% of children under the age of 14 years, and 2-10% in adults. This very common condition has a significant emotional, social and economic impact on the sufferer and his/her family, and thus it is important for all healthcare clinicians to be familiar and up-to-date with the disease and its therapeutic management based on "Evidence".
Stedman’s medical dictionary defines Eczema as: Generic term for inflammatory conditions of the skin, particularly with vesiculation in the acute stage, typically erythematous, edematous, papular, and crusting; followed often by lichenification and scaling and occasionally by duskiness of the erythema and, infrequently, hyperpigmentation; often accompanied by sensations of itching and burning; the vesicles form by intraepidermal spongiosis; often hereditary and associated with allergic rhinitis and asthma.
This definition, like most definitions of eczema, to a large extent is defining atopic eczema, which will also be the focus of this paper, but for completeness and to assist in differentiating AD from the other types of eczema, the other types of eczema will be mentioned in the differential diagnosis of Atopic Eczema towards the end of this paper as well.
Some writers use the classification of endogenous eczema to mean atopic eczema and exogenous to include irritant and allergic contact dermatitis. Others classify the patients with AD who are allergic as extrinsic and those without as intrinsic eczema.
"Atopy" is defined as a form of allergy in which there is a hereditary or constitutional tendency to develop hypersensitivity reactions. This tendency to produce specific IgE responses to allergens is associated with "atopic" eczema, but up to 40% of individuals with the disease phenotype may not be atopic. This makes continued use of the term atopic eczema somewhat problematic. A more useful nomenclature of Atopic eczema / dermatitis syndrome (AEDS), which was proposed by the European Academy of Allergology and Clinical Immunology (EAACI) Nomenclature Task Force in 2001 has been updated by the World Allergy Organization in 2004.( Ref Johansson et al, JACI, 2004). The new nomenclature is based on the mechanisms that initiate and mediate allergic reactions. The term "eczema" is proposed to replace the provisional term Atopic eczema / dermatitis syndrome (AEDS). The term ‘atopy’ should not be used until an IgE sensitization has been documented by IgE antibodies in the blood of a person or a positive skin prick test to common environmental allergens such as dust mites, pollens , or cat. The term eczema can therefore be split into ‘atopic eczema’ and non-atopic eczema’.
This WAO nomenclature further classifies contact eczema as follows:
- Delayed hypersensitivity caused by close contact with low-molecular–weight chemicals (like nickel) which provoke a predominantly TH1 lymphocyte-mediated allergic contact dermatitis.
- The non-allergic variety can also be described by terms like irritant contact dermatitis.
Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Atopic Dermatitis
Case 1: Atopic Eczema secondary to egg allergy
Cade developed eczema on cheeks at 6 weeks while he was being breast-fed. Mom suspected that he was reacting to her breast milk since she thought at times he was very unsettled after feeding. At 2 months he had his first attempt at a cow’s milk formula and spat it out and developed peri-oral urticaria. Mother assumed a cow’s milk allergy and decided to breast-feed only. Despite exclusive breast-feeding the eczema progressively got worse. It required twice daily hydrocortisone creams and intermittent locoid cream to keep it moderately controlled.
At 6 months when he came to see me, he had chronic eczema on his cheeks in his flexures and also few small urticarial plaques on his trunk.
Skin Prick Test:
Milk=4mm, Egg=12mm, wheat=0, soy=0, peanut=6mm
House dust mites=0, cat=0, dog=0.
Management and Progress
Mother was told to eliminate eggs and peanut from her diet as well as the milk which she had been eliminating for the last 4 months. Weaning onto a hypoallergenic formula was recommended, but mom preferred to continue breast-feeding (with omission of milk and eggs from her diet) for another 3 months.
In 2 weeks she was able to reduce the hydrocortisone to alternate days and the skin was free of eczema.
Case 2: Contact Dermatitis to several agents used to treat eczema, masquerading as atopic eczema
Glenys is a 51 yr-old non-atopic female who developed eczema for the first time 2 years prior to her consulting me. The rash started on her hands and then gradually spread to limbs, then trunk then involved entire body, including her face.
She has seen numerous doctors and alternative practitioners and tried several topical steroids including Locoid, which she though made the rash much worse. She also tried several antihistamines and several different herbal creams and supplements. She had moderate benefit from a 2 month course of prednisone. At one stage was prescribed fluoxetine, which she took for 3 months and thought that it gave the best relief to the intense itching.
A herbal cream containing tea tree oil.
Multivitamins and flaxoil which she has been on for 18 months.
Of significance, she was also using a shampoo containing chamomile.
Patches of chronic lichenified eczema on legs, and trunk. There was evidence of excoriations especially on legs.
Skin Prick Test: were negative to 20 common environment and food allergens.
Patch Test: Positive to fragrance 1, tea tree oil and compositae at 48 hrs and 72 hrs and weak positive reactions to budesonide hydrocortisone butyrate and tixocortal pivolate at 72 hrs.
Extended steroid patch test showed that she was tolerant to mometasone.
Allergic contact dermatitis to tea tree oils, fragrances and steroids.
Her eczema improved after stopping her herbal cream and using mometsone ointment and a fragrance-free moisturizer.
Atopic Dermatitis: A Skin Barrier Disease
Barrier Function of the skin
An intact epidermis is a prerequisite for the skin to function as a physical and chemical barrier. The barrier is the stratum corneum, which forms a brick and mortar-like structure of the upper epidermal layer. An alteration of the barrier that causes increased transepidermal water loss is the hallmark of atopic dermatitis.
For a long time efforts to understand the etiology and pathophysiology of atopic dermatitis concentrated on the immune system. Due to very important recent discoveries in the last few years increasing attention has been paid to the barrier-forming epidermis.
The innate immune system in Atopic dermatitis
The epithelial cells are the first line of defense between the skin and the environment. The epithelial sensing structures for pathogens are abnormal in AD, which is one of the reasons bacterial, viral and fungal infections are more common in patients with AD.
Triggers for atopic eczema
In understanding the pathogenesis (hopefully leading to better management) of atopic eczema it is important to remember that it is a multifactorial disease with multiple triggers. The triggers also vary depending on the genetics, age, environment and even the psyche (mindset) of the individual. Therefore, not every patient will react to every trigger. The most important triggers based on evidence based medicine include:
- Dry skin (almost universal due to defective barrier function):
- Climate: winter, excess sweating
- long frequent hot showers.
- Staph infection (and other microbes)
- Food allergy in infants*
- soaps, detergents, wet work
- cigarette smoke
- clothing: wool, synthetic fibers
- habitual scratching.
- Environmental allergens (house dust mites, pollens, pets)
- Emotional stresses (school exams, work pressures, relationship problems)
- Iatrogenic - Irritant or allergic contact dermatitis to topical treatment
- Hormonal: Pregnancy and menstrual cycle
Evidence based medicine on what causes Worsening of Eczema
Food allergy in children suffering from atopic eczema
There should no longer be any controversy in the fact that food is a significant trigger for eczema in infancy.
Studies showing prevalence of food allergy (proven by DBPC food challenges) in children with eczema:
Sampson & McCaskill
Burks et al
Niggeman et al
Eigenman & Calza
Staph Aureus and Atopic Eczema
S. aureus rarely colonises normal skin. Only 2% of adolescents and adults are colonized in non-specialized skin sites, although this increases to 35% in the anterior nares and 5-15% in the axillae, perineum and toe webs. This is in contrast with almost universal colonization among atopic dermatitis patients.
Super antigens in AD
Numerous studies have shown that superantigens produced by staph aureus play a central pathogenic role in AD. These enterotoxins are more potent than most antigens at stimulating the immune system.
- Superantigens trigger mast cell degranulation directly and amplify IgE-mediated allergic reactions.
- Superantigens induce dermatitis on application to skin by patch testing.
The importance of s aureus colonization in AD is supported by the observation that not only patients with impetiginised AD, but also AD patients without superinfection, show a synergistic clinical response to combined treatment with antistaphylococcal antibiotics and topical steroids.
House dust mites and aeroallergens causing eczema
Three provocation studies suggest an association between exposure and flares, and this evidence is also supported by 2 patch test studies.
Stress causing eczema
Kimata studied the impact of road traffic, video games and ringing mobile phones on wheal response and neuropeptides in eczema (not eczema severity) in 2 provocation case control studies. In all 3 groups, increased wheal responses, substance P, VIP, and nerve growth factor were increased in the eczema group but not in controls.
Effect of UV radiation on atopic eczema
Deguchi H et al felt that sun exposure is an aggravating factor responsible for the recalcitrant facial erythema in adult patients with atopic dermatitis, however the result of this study of sun exposure on an unselected group of patients with recalcitrant facial eczema is unclear.
Atopic eczema or atopic dermatitis is a common inflammatory, chronically relapsing, extremely pruritic skin disease. It has a wide spectrum of dermatologic manifestations. There is no definitive ‘gold standard’ for the diagnosis of atopic eczema. and uniformity in the use of diagnostic criteria is lacking From a systematic review looking at several sets of criteria the UK Diagnostic Criteria were found to be the most extensively validated. However, there is room for improvement in methodological design for future intervention studies, but I think it is probably the best we have at present.
A carefully taken history using the UK Diagnostic criteria followed by a full examination of the patient should diagnose most cases of true atopic eczema.
The UK Diagnostic Criteria for Atopic Dermatitis
Must have an itchy skin condition over the past 12 months, PLUS 3 or more of the following:
- Onset below the age of 2
- History of flexural involvement (around the eyes, around the neck, front of elbows, behind knees, front of ankles)
- Generally dry skin
- Personal or (in children under 4 years) allergic disease in parents or siblings
- Visible flexural dermatitis (around the eyes, around the neck, front of elbows, behind the knees, front of ankles).
Clinical Features of Atopic Dermatitis (AD)
- AD usually begins early in life; 45% of al cases begin within the first 6 months of life, 57% of cases begin by age 2 years, and 87% of cases by the age of 5 years
- The principal feature of AD is pruritus, which is universally present (almost 100% negative predictive value), and scratching is a major factor in the pathogenesis of the acute and chronic lesions. "If it does not itch its probably not eczema"
- Early lesions of AD are erythematous and dry with small papules, mild scaling, and areas of excoriation.
- Lesions that are moist and oozing or those with intense erythema suggest the possibility of superficial secondary infection.
- Chronically affected areas show accentuated skin lines and thickening of the skin (lichenification) and post-inflammatory pigment abnormalities are common (especially in dark skin).
- The pattern of distribution of AD lesions changes with age. Areas affected in infants include the cheeks, trunk and extensor surfaces of the extremities. The area around the nose is never involved, and this "headlight "sign is characteristic of AD.
- During childhood and adolescence, the distribution shifts to the flexures and the neck.
- The severity of AD tends to decrease after childhood, although occupational eczema and increased skin sensitization is common.
Other types of eczema that is often confused with AD
Eczema in the broadest sense (inflammation of the epidermis and dermis) is a component of many skin diseases. Despite this, eczema can be very easily diagnosed visually. The real problem is usually in differentiating the different types of eczema. Some find it easy to classify eczema (dermatitis) into those diseases that are caused by external factors (exogenous dermatitis), namely irritant contact dermatitis and allergic contact dermatitis, and those that do not require external induction or endogenous eczema, the commonest examples being atopic eczema and seborrheic dermatitis.
Classification of Eczema: Differential Diagnosis of Atopic Eczema
- Contact Dermatitis
- Irritant contact dermatitis
- Allergic Contact dermatitis.
- Atopic Eczema
- Dishidrotic Dermatitis or Pompholyx
- Neurodermatitis or lichen simplex chronicus
- Nummular eczema
- Unclassified Eczema or Nonspecific Endogenous Eczema.
Contact dermatitis is the term for the type of eczema resulting from exposure to allergens (allergic contact dermatitis) or irritants (irritant contact dermatitis).
Contact dermatitis accounts for at least 60% of occupational skin diseases.
Seborrheic dermatitis is a common, inflammatory skin condition that causes flaky, white to yellowish scales to form on oily (sebum rich) areas such as the scalp, inside the ear, the sides of the nose, between the eyebrows and the midsternal area. It can occur with or without erythema.
Dishidrotic Dermatitis or Pompholyx
- Other synonym is vesicular palmoplantar eczema.
- It causes small vesicles on the palms and sides of the fingers and soles of the feet.
- Intense burning or itching.
- Excessive sweating in affected areas.
- Risk factors:
- stress, female gender
- hot weather
- Pre-existing atopy and contact dermatitis
- Smoking, oral contraceptives, aspirin.
Neurodermatitis or Lichen simplex
These are types of eczema that are thought to be self-induced by habitual scratching, and are usually localized. Common areas affected include, the lower legs, scrotum and vulvae. They are usually very difficult to treat and sometimes require intralesional injection of steroids and psychotherapeutics.
Nummular (meaning "coin-shaped") dermatitis is a form of eczema, characterized by round-to-oval erythematous plaques most commonly found on the arms and legs. Lesions start as papules, which then coalesce into plaques. Early lesions may be studded with vesicles containing serous exudates. They are usually very pruritic. Very little is known about the pathogenesis, except an increased amount of mast cells is usually found in these lesions, compared to non-lesional skin.
Ichthyosis is the term used to describe continual and widespread scaling of the skin. The skin is very dry, thickened and scaled. It is associated with increased wrinkling of the palms and soles and increased skin infections. It comes from a Greek root "Ichthy", meaning fish. It may be inherited (genetic) or acquired during life. The inherited forms are rare and are generally present from infancy and are usually lifelong conditions. Acquired Ichthyosis can develop at any age due to a number of medical problems, such as kidney disease.
Unclassified Eczema (UE) or Nonspecific Endogenous Eczema
The term nonspecific endogenous eczema (dermatitis) is preferred because a major criterion for diagnosis is the exclusion of exogenous contact factors. These are patients with eczema that does not fit any of the distinct patterns above.
Unclassified eczema is a common type of eczema with a very poor prognosis. This is a diagnosis of exclusion. The diagnosis is made after atopic eczema, allergic contact dermatitis, seborrhoeic dermatitis and the other well defined forms of eczema are excluded.
Differences between atopic eczema, seborrhoeic dermatitis and allergic contact dermatitis
Probably the conditions that are most often confused with AD are allergic contact dermatitis and infantile seborrhoeic dermatitis.
In one study 2% patients tested were allergic to topical steroids and also equally (2%) to propylene glycol.
Allergens associated with medications used to treat eczema include:
- Allergy to Corticosteroids
- The incidence of contact allergy to corticosteroids has increased dramatically since the late 1980’s.
- Allergic Contact dermatitis due to:
- fragrance in moisturisers
- Vehicles in creams
Propylene glycol is present in Elide, cetaphil, and some topical steroids
An irritant reaction (burning, stinging, itching or redness within 20 minutes of applying the cream) occurs in >56% of children with atopic eczema when aqueous cream is used as an emollient, compared to only 17% of children using other emollients, according to an audit published in Pharmaceutical Journal.
Investigations in Eczema
- Skin Prick Test (SPT)
- Can be done to confirm atopy or to assist in the diagnosis of food allergy. A positive test to a food only confirm sensitivity and this needs to be followed up with an oral challenge (ideally double-blind).
- Atopy Patch Test (APT)
- APT using common food allergens (like milk, eggs) applied to the skin of the upper back for 48 hours, and read again at 72 hrs, has become a very useful way of picking up non-IgE (delayed) reactions to these foods. APT was found to be more sensitive and specific method than skin prick test or RAST-type tests, in diagnosing delayed food allergy in children with AD. The combination of SPT and APT significantly enhances identification of food allergy in children with AD.
- Patch Test
- Should be considered in all cases of AD that is not responding to conventional treatment with topical steroids and emollients, since this is the only way to diagnose a secondary allergic contact dermatitis to the topical steroids or one of the vehicles in the creams being used.
- Oral Food Challenges (Double-blind Placebo-controlled)
- This is the ‘gold standard’ for diagnosing food allergy as a trigger for atopic eczema. One of the drawbacks to this test is that it is very time-consuming and the flare-up of eczema can be delayed outside of the observation period.
Evidence based management of Atopic Dermatitis
A multifaceted Approach to the Treatment of AD
A multipronged approach is required for treatment of AD. This should include:
- Skin hydration
- Control of itching
- Look for and Remove triggers / exacerbating factors
- Emotional stress
Moisturizer and emollients
Emollients and moisturizers are used interchangeably, but technically speaking, "moisturizer" adds moisture to the skin and "emollients" soften the skin. An ideal preparation for dry skin should have both properties.
Since we now know that defective skin barrier function is the primary or underlying cause of atopic eczema, it is easier to understand why moisturizers and emollients are so important in its management. It is important to emphasize to patients that they will need to make a habit of using moisturizers daily, for the rest of their life, regardless of whether their eczema is in remission or not.
The faulty skin barrier causes an increase in transepidermal water loss. As a result, the corneocytes shrink and cracks open between them, permitting the penetration of irritants and/or allergens, and causing the development of eczematous lesions. Even in normal skin, repeated use of soaps and solvents produces eczematous reaction in the same way because they remove the epidermal lipids.
Essentially emollients are lipid containing agents that provide a lipid film that sits on the surface of the skin and encourages the build up of water in the stratum corneum. They do this mostly by preventing the evaporation of water from the skin surface. One study has shown that emollients may reduce the need for topical steroids by about 50%.
In New Zealand there is a vast array of moisturizers / emollients to choose from, but they all work in one or more of the following ways:
- Occlusive Moisturizers: These contain oils such as liquid paraffin (mineral oil), white soft paraffin, yellow soft paraffin, wool fat or lanoline, coconut oil, or emulsifying wax. They all work by providing a layer of oil on the surface of the skin, which prevents evaporation of water from the skin surface. These oils may be mixed with varying amounts of water to produce moisturizer with different properties, e.g. lotions, creams or ointments.
- Humectant moisturizers: contain ingredient such as urea, glycerin, lactic acid, glycolic acid, which penetrate into the stratum corneum, where they attract and retain water. They are particularly useful in very dry skin.
- Keratolytics: In chronic eczema there is a build up of a skin protein called keratin, which makes the skin hard and scaly. At higher concentrations lactic acid and glycolic acid act as keratolytics, which means they have the ability to break down the keratin in hardened and thickened skin. Some of the moisturizers will have these keratolytics added for this purpose.
Finding the most suitable emollient for an individual is a matter of trial and error, but some basic rules apply.
Tips for choosing the best moisturizer / emollient:
- The key to getting the best out of moisturizers /emollients is education.
- In theory greasier oil based products are more effective but these are rarely tolerated and are not used by people with mild to moderate eczema.
- Lotions are mixtures of oil in water, and are light & non-greasy, and have a cooling effect. They are good for mildly dry & weeping eczema. They are also good for hairy areas, such as scalp.
- Creams are also mixtures of oil in water, but slightly thicker than lotions. They are generally non-greasy, and easily absorbed. They are therefore more cosmetically acceptable than ointments.
- Ointments are thick, occlusive oil based moisturizers that is most suitable for very dry skin. Many patients don’t like them , as they find them too greasy.
- It is best to let children choose their favorite emollient.
- Caregivers should specifically ask about skin reactions like stinging, burning, itching or redness after using emollients before, and avoid prescribing them.
- Urea-containing emollients are of great help to patients with atopic dermatitis.
How to use emollients
- Emollients should be used directly after bath or shower.
- It is important to emphasize the importance of using moisturizer at least twice daily.
- The application of moisturizer and topical steroids should be separated by at least 1 hour to avoid dilution of the steroid.
- If applied several times daily to the whole body children will require at least 250g per week and adults 500g per week.
Adverse reactions to emollients and moisturizers
- Allergic contact dermatitis: Apart from paraffin and water, almost any ingredient of emollients may sensitize. Patch testing will help to identify contact allergens. The main sensitizers are:
- Perfumes / fragrances
- Preservatives (antimicrobials)
- Propylene glycol
Glucocoticoids are the mainstay of anti-inflammatory therapy in the management of chronic AD. Topical steroids will help majority of patients with AD, and absolute steroid insensitivity is unusual, but a spectrum of steroid responsiveness exists. From the observation that combined treatment of AD with antibiotics and steroids is more effective than steroids alone, this would suggest that s. aureus secrete products that can induce steroid insensitivity. Recently Leung et al made the discovery that when T-cells are stimulated with superantigens, as compared to other stimuli, they become insensitive to the immunosuppressive effects of steroids.
Topical Corticosteroids in NZ Classified by relative potencies
Principles of prescribing Topical Steroids
Amount of steroids prescribed
Adult: 30 g for whole body once
- 3g for head and face
- 3g for an arm
- 6g for a leg
- 9-12g for the trunk.
Fingertip units for application of topical steroids
One fingertip unit is the amount of cream that is squeezed out of a standard 5mm size nozzle along an adult fingertip. Two fingertip units is about the same as 1gm of topical steroids.
Adverse effects of topical steroids
The local side effects of using potent steroids for long period of time (such as striae, skin atrophy, telangiectasia, perioral dermatitis, erythema, acne, glaucoma and cataract) are well described, and well known to all of us and will not be discussed any further.
Probably what is not so well known is the increasingly recognized side effect of allergic contact dermatitis to the steroid molecule. Contact allergy to topical corticosteroids is sufficiently common to justify their inclusion for patch testing in the standard series and tixocortol pivalate and budesonide have been recommended as contact allergy markers.
Rational approach to treating staph infection in AD
Staph colonization rates are lower in clinically uninvolved skin than in lichenified or inflamed skin, and highest in acute weeping lesions, with the density of colonization being roughly proportional to the severity of eczema.
Staph Infection & AD
- Staph is found on 90% of AD skin vs 5% of non-AD skin
- The majority of AD staph produce superantigens, which induces inflammation
- T-cells activated by superantigens are steroid insensitive
- Combination of antibiotics/corticosteroid therapy is more effective than either therapy alone.
Oral Antibiotics in Eczema
Signs of bacterial infection in atopic eczema include:
- Pustules or cellulitis
- A sudden worsening of the eczema.
In these cases oral antibiotics should be prescribed. In New Zealand flucloxacillin and dicloxacillin are commonly prescribed. In case of penicillin allergy erythromycin is used.
Swabs for bacteriology are always a good idea, but are particularly useful if patients do not respond to treatment, in order to identify antibiotic resistant strains of S. aureus or to detect additional streptococcal infection.
Topical Immunomodulators (Tacrolimus and pimecrolimus (elidel®)
Tacrolimus (which is not currently available topically in NZ) is probably as strong as betamethasone valerate (potent steroid). NICE guideline recommends tacrolimus for moderate to severe eczema that has not responded to appropriate potency topical steroids.
Pimecrolimus (Elidel®): is less potent than tacrolimus. There is some evidence that it prevents flares of atopic eczema. It is useful for head and neck eczema.
Despite the concerns expressed by the US FDA about their potential to cause malignancies, to date there are no data supporting an increased incidence of cutaneous malignancies or lymphoma in patients treated with these drugs.
In New Zealand Elidel® is recommended for short-term or intermittent long-term treatment of AD in patients >= 3 months when topical steroids are ineffective, intolerable or inappropriate. My personal experience is that it is not very effective for treating flare-ups, but better at preventing eczema of the face and neck (part of the maintenance regimen).
Do oral antihistamines stop the itch of AD? The Evidence
There are no good studies investigating the efficacy of oral antihistamines in AD. The evidence to date is that it does not relieve the itch, but can be useful if they have sedating properties.
Infants with eczema that is being triggered by food allergy will often have superimposed urticaria with their eczema and can have dramatic improvement from oral non-sedating antihistamines.
Systemic Treatment of Severe Atopic Eczema
Cyclosporine usually leads to prompt relief of symptoms within 2 weeks of starting treatment. However, following cessation of therapy, relapse within 6 weeks is common. Adverse effects include renal toxicity, hypertension, nausea and abdominal pain.
2 small RCT looked at systemic steroids in children. Unfortunately no data was identified for prednisone, which would be the standard systemic steroids in NZ. Anecdotally, the big problem with systemic steroids in treating atopic eczema is the frequent rebound on stopping.
Azothiaprine can be very effective in treating severe AD, but is a slower acting medication (4 – 6 weeks), and has the potential to cause bone marrow suppression, hepatotoxicity, squamous cell carcinoma and lymphomas.
This drug can lead to improvement in AD after 8 and 12 weeks of treatment.
Phototherapy has an anti-inflammatory effect on the cells of the immune system. Types of UV therapy that have been used successfully in treating AD include psoralen and UVA (PUVA), combination of broadband UVA/UVB, broadband UVA, broadband UVB, narrowband UVB (311nm), and UVA1 (340-400nm). Adverse effects include premature aging of the skin and increased likelihood of squamous cell carcinoma and melanoma.
Prevention of Atopic Dermatitis (AD)
In the case of primary prevention (preventing AD in high risk individuals), there is no evidence that exclusive breastfeeding, infant avoidance of allergens, mother avoidance of certain foods or aeroallergens will prevent the development of AD. There are some conflicting reports of treatment with probiotics, particularly Lactobacillus, during pregnancy or infancy may delay the onset of AD in infants and children.
Education in evidence based management of AD
Some recent studies have shown that patient education through a nurse practitioner may be able to improve patient concordance and, as a consequence, can reduce the unnecessary use of topical steroids in atopic eczema. The studies showed that the education requires time, that is often not available in a busy clinic.
Basic education in management of atopic dermatitis should include:
- Skin barrier function is abnormal and Importance of daily emollients for life
- Control vs cure
- Identify the individual triggers including foods
- Signs of infection
- Provide written individual treatment plan
- Offer educational websites or support groups.
Advice against career choices that may exacerbate AD or lead to hand eczema:
- Cook or cleaner
- Factory worker (wet work)
Identify and discuss hidden concerns (what patients / parents often aren’t telling you):
- They are looking for a cure
- Parents fear that the child will be permanently scarred
- They have steroid phobia and does not like long-term use of antihistamines and therefore compliance is an issue
- They are concerned about food allergy being a cause
- They are keen to try or are trying alternative therapies.
Consider a therapist /counseling if there is:
- Significant family distress or dysfunction
- Excessive absence from school (especially if out of proportion to AD severity
- Poor coping skills (family or child)
- Evidence of depression, obsessive-compulsive disorder, or neurotic scratching / excoriations.
Unconventional Treatment of AD and evidence for using them (or not)
Immunotherapy for Atopic Eczema
It has been shown that reduction of the house dust mite allergen load is effective as preventative and therapeutic measure in atopic Eczema. Furthermore, recent data indicate that specific immunotherapy with house dust mite allergen is effective in patients with atopic eczema.
"Wet wrap" bandages
Wet wraps can occasionally be a helpful treatment in infants and young children where limb scratching is a major problem. It involves the application of a weak topical steroid, like 1% hydrocortisone ointment or just emollients under an inner wet and an outer dry layer of cotton tubular bandage or garment. At present clear evidence for wet wraps is very limited. There is some concern about side effects, with regards to applying steroids under occlusion in children.
From my clinical experience, wet wraps with 1% hydrocortisone is particularly helpful to break the itch-scratch cycle in kids who have developed habitual scratching.
Alternative Medicines in Atopic Dermatitis
Alternative medicine has been termed as a means of therapy or examination that has no scientific basis, and no effective or diagnostic reliability validation has been demonstrated. The use of such medicine is increasing, without the benefit of controlled trials on the subject. Alternative medicines for treating eczema are very popular in New Zealand.
Some of the alternative remedies used in New Zealand to treat eczema include:
- Chinese Herbs
- Evening primrose oil – Studies have failed to show benefit Dietary restriction without scientific testing (Alternative testing).
Chinese herbal creams
Parents consider herbal remedies as natural products that are usually derived from plants, and therefore should be harmless. Some of these products are also very effective in clearing stubborn eczema. In 1999 Keane et al analyzed 11 herbal creams obtained from children attending dermatology outpatient clinics in the UK. Eight of the 11 creams contained dexamethasone at concentrations inappropriate for use on the face of children. In 2003 the Ministry of Health’s Medicines Safety Authority in New Zealand, (Medsafe) recalled a herbal cream that illegally contained potent steroids (clobetasol propionate ) and ketaconazole. Again in 2005 herbal products were recalled for containing betamethasone.
Summary of Treatment options for Atopic Eczema
Recommendations for referral for Specialist care
- Uncertainty of the diagnosis
- If severe infection with herpes simplex (eczema herpeticum) is associated with systemic symptoms urgent referral is recommended
- If secondarily infected eczema is not responding to appropriate oral antibiotics plus adequate potency topical steroids
- If food allergy is suspected in infancy
- If eczema is causing significant social or psychological problems
- If contact dermatitis is suspected and confirmation is required by patch testing.
Checklist for recalcitrant eczema: Why is the eczema not improving?
- Lack of Compliance due to steroid phobia
- Food Allergy in infants
- Secondary infection (staph, viruses, fungi)
- Iatrogenic Dermatitis due to
- Co-existence of a contact dermatitis related to creams being used
- Irritant dermatitis.
- Emotional / Psychological stresses causing habitual scratching
- More education needed: especially on the important role of emollients.
Some Key References
- Brenninkmeijer EE et al. Diagnostic Criteria for Atopic Dermatitis: A Systematic review. Br J Dermatol. 2008;158(4): 754-765
- Rance F et al Food allergy in children suffering from atopic eczema Pediatr Allergy Immunol 2008: 19: 279-284
- Williams HC, Burney PG et al. The UK working Party’s Diagnostic Criteria for Atopic Dermatitis I. Derivation of a minimum set of discriminators for atopic dermatitis. Br J Dermatol 1994;131:383-96
- Eigenmann PA et al Prevalence of IgE-mediated food allergy among children with AD. Pediatrics 1998;101:E8
- Schmitt J et al Systemic Treatment of Atopic Eczema: A Systematic review. Acta Derm Venerol 2007;87: 100-111
- B Li L-f et al Prognosis of unclassified eczema: a follow-up study. Arch Dermatol. 2008;144(2): 160-164
- Sichere SH et al Food hypersensitivity and AD: pathophysiology, epedimiology, diagnosis, and management. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1999;104: S114-S122
- Ottens S et al More than 50% of positive challenge with foods are associated with late eczematous reactions in AD Allergy Clin Immunol Int 2006
- Tupker RA et al Induction of eczema by inhalation of dust mite. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1996; 97:1064-70
- Wanukul S et al Eczematous skin reaction from patch testing with aeroallergens in atopic children with and without atopic dermatitis. Pediatr Dermatol 1993; 10: 209-13
- Hoare C, Li Wan Po A et al., Systematic review of treatment for atopic eczema. Southampton National Coordinating Centre for HTA, 2000 (Health Technology Assessment; Vol 4)
- Wolkerstorfer A, et al Efficacy and safety of wet wrap dressing in children with severe atopic dermatitis: influence of corticosteroid dilution. Br J Dermatol 2000;143: 999-1004
- Novak N, Bieber T. Allergic and non-allergic forms of atopic diseases. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2003;112:252-262
- Burden AD, Beck MH. Contact Hypersensitivity to topical steroids. Br J Dermatol. 1992 Nov;127(5):497-500
- Wanukul S et al Eczematous skin reaction from patch testing with aeroallergens in atopic children with and without atopic dermatitis. Pediatr Dermatol 1993; 10: 209-13
- Cork ML et al An audit of adverse drug reactions to aqueous cream in children with atopic dermatitis. The Pharmaceutical Journal. Nov. 2003. Vol.271